Showdown: The 10th Versus the 11th Doctor

If you love Doctor Who, you have a favorite Doctor. While some prefer the dark humor of Nine, and others enjoy more retro Doctors, competition is fiercest between the two most recent incarnations: David Tennant’s Tenth Doctor and Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor. Figment is stepping in to settle this feud once and for all with the definitive Doctor Showdown!

Round 1: Who Wore it Best?

It’s tough to choose between two Doctors who are also iconic dressers. Is it Ten’s Converse/trench/3D glasses combo? Or Eleven’s fez/bowtie/suspenders look? In the end, we have to say Eleven takes it. His clothes look like they could be on a mannequin at Urban Outfitters. Super hipster chic.

Round 2: Best Catchphrase

No contest, this has to go to Ten. “Allons-y” is way more iconic than Eleven’s underutilized “Geronimo.” Now, we’re tempted to give this category to River Song, because “Spoilers” has become the siren song to all Who-fans since her first appearance at The Library.

Round 3: Best Companion

Ten’s got more air time on Eleven, and that may help contribute to his victory. One on one, you could argue that Amy Pond could take any of Ten’s companions, but there’s no way she can beat Rose AND Donna AND Martha AND Jack AND K9 AND Sarah Jane AND all the other assorted friends and family who fell in with the Who crew.

Round 4: Best Hair

This might be the most controversial call we’ve ever made, but we’re choosing Matt Smith’s swoop over David Tennant’s spikes. Don’t hurt us.

Round 5: Best Acting

Guys, Matt Smith won a BAFTA for his performance of The Doctor. I don’t want to defer to the British Academy, but we’re gonna hafta go Eleventh Doctor, which means…

The Eleventh Doctor wins!

Did we fail it or nail it? Leave your comments below and tell us what two characters should have a showdown next!

147 thoughts on “Showdown: The 10th Versus the 11th Doctor

  1. Oh, this is the hardest decision ever. I agree that best hair is probably the hardest call to make. I tend to lean toward 11 anyways, but it was hard to see him beat 10. Even with his puppy-dog face.

    • Honestly, for hair, I’m going to have to go with 10. 11’s hair is great, but nothing beats 10’s iconic spikes. Plus, if we’re counting hair on faces, 10 would win because (no offense) 11 doesn’t really have any eyebrows.

  2. *sniff* I refuse to choose between Doctors. Personally, all eleven are excellent, and although a Whovian might have a preference for one over the other, they are all equally good.

  3. Well, I started hits show with ten, and you never forget your first doctor, so… Plus, tens hair is totally better than elevens!

    • I agree you never forget your first Doctor. I personally started with Nine. I’m one of those people that came in late and went to Netflix and to the beginning. I’m still in the middle of Ten, in season three and I think I just started getting used to him.

      • Me too! Christopher Eccleson, number nine, was a personal favorite because he was the first doctor because I started on Netflix. I’m in the season finale of season 4 and I don’t want Ten to die! Ten should’ve won!

        • I also started on Netflix with Chris Eccleston but, personally I loved Ten. Nine and Eleven were/are both awesome but Ten will probably always be my absolute favorite

          • I agree with Hailey – I started with Eccleston but Tennant is my favorite! Matt Smith has been growing on me though…

          • I also started on Netflix with christopher Eccleston, I’ll never forget him but personally I love the tenth and eleventh, I lean towards tenth though because eleven sometimes kills the bad guy and tenth refused to touch a gun

          • MY FAVORITE IS TENNAT, AND WHEN HE CHANGED I CRIED A LOT!!! BECAUSE HE WAS SAD IN THAT MOMENT AND HE DIDNT WANT TO CHANGE. AND IM NOT GOING TO GET OVER IT ALL THE INCREDIBLE SCENES TENNAT DID. WAS EPIC.

    • That’s true, your first Doctor is almost always your favorite. I started with Eleven, but as the old saying goes, ” You either love David Tennant, or you’ve never met him.” WHY DO THEY HAVE A SHOWDOWN WITH THE TWO BEST?

    • I started with nine and he has been my favorite ever since.

      And I was totally thinking the same thing!! The way Ten runs his fingers through his hair and then pulls it straight out, making his hair an even bigger mess, gosh! It’s amazing, I tell you. Amazing. ^_^

    • “Your first Doctor you never forget.” THat is not at all true for me. I started with the Ninth, and he is not my favorite. Ten made me love the show, and Eleven made me think the show was going to make me drown in all my tears. They are the ones that are my favorites, not Nine (even though I love him and giant ears)

      • I agree that eccleston was incredible, and that there is too much hate against him for leaving after one season, but I would like to point out that HE WANTED TO LEAVE after one season. And when Tennant regenerated and said “I don’t want to go” that was how David Tennant personally felt. And eleven simply belongs in a mental institution.

        • Umm what did you just say about eleven? If he’s in a mental institution ten is a crook that kills people all the time. Look I know eleven is ecentric but I wouldn’t go that far.

    • Bless you for saying it. It might be the standard ‘you never forget your first Doctor,’ because I started with Nine, but he is hands down my favorite.

  4. Sorry, totally disagree. Also, I take personal offense over the exclusion of Nine. Because he’s perf.
    Ten wore it best.
    Nine’s catchphrase is fantastic.
    Ten’s floopy (yes I spelled that how I meant to) hair was my favorite ever.
    The acting, though, is a three-way tie for sure. I genuinely can’t choose.

  5. This decision is so hard! The only one I would disagree with is the hair. 10’s sticky-uppy hair is great. But I’m glad 11 won. He was a)my first doctor, who you never forget, and b) he was the one that made me fall in love with Doctor Who. So I adopted him as “my doctor” and I’m rather partial to him.

  6. NOT COOL, FIGMENT. NOT COOL AT ALL. I get the Eleven supporters, but is the hair even a QUESTION? Eleven’s known for the clothes. Ten’s known for the hair. At least give him the hair. Come on.

    What about category for most feels? Cause that would also go to Ten…

  7. Oooh, I love Ten way too much!! (And really? You gave the hair to Eleven?! What is the world of awesome hair coming to?) Eleven is just too bumbley to me…Ten had a sharpness about him while still being fun. You can say Eleven is the best…but Ten is my favorite!!! (Of the recent Doctors that is…). 😉

  8. WHY IN ALL OF SPACE AND TIME WOULD YOU EXCLUDE NINE??? That’s just not fair. I love Ten and Eleven with all my heart, but (yes) Nine was my first Doctor, and he will always be near and dear to my heart. <3

  9. PSHHHH!!! You guys are NUTS! David Tennant (10th Doctor) is the best Doctor ever! Everything about him was awesome. Especially that hair. Really great hair.

  10. FAIL FAIL FAIL. You cannot have a best Doctor. They are all the same person. Also, any New Who discussion is incomplete and doomed to fail when they COMPLETELY IGNORE NINE and say “Who-fans” (what? what? what!) instead of Whovians.

    For your sake, Figment, I won’t even start on the hair fiasco.

  11. I have to agree, you never forget your first doctor. Thus, nine is my doctor, but I’m partial to ten because he’s also Hamlet, and Scottish, and I love eleven’s quirks! (I’m only through season 5 though so we’ll see) You want me to choose a favorite? Shame on you!

    Also, why was nine not included in this competition?

  12. If we’re complaining about regenerations being excluded, you can consider this my hearty protest at that Eight wasn’t in the running for best hair.

  13. How can you say Matt Smith’s hair is better then David Tennet’s?! David’s hair is obviously better. Look at it! It practically defies gravity!

    • Yeah, no. Eleven is SOOOOO much better. If you haven’t noticed when eleven was an old man he killed billions of his enemie’s protecting Chrismas. He spent most of his eleventh incarnation protecting them BEAT THAT TEN.

  14. But-but-but….. The HAIR! HOW could rule Matt smith over David!!!! (yes first name basis)! And the acting I might give you but still….. David tennant. Come on.

  15. In my opinion, out of newho, Nine is best

    And I don’t understand your logic on the hair, how could you resist David’s amazing hair????

  16. Hell no! No no no no no! Tennant put his life and his passion into his acting and dear God he is the most iconic person I have ever seen in television.

    • Look dude. I’m not going to do all of my incredibly long rambling, just read this WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

  17. I’m a sucker for Six. He had terrible writers, and worse producers, but CB is a stonking actor, and really brought out the Doctor’s alien personality. Nine was fantastic, and Eleven has the “old eyes in a young face” down perfectly. Eight was under-used, but makes a great Doctor in the audio adventures. Seven was brilliant, and Ten was… well, Tennant. What more can you say?

    Four was loud, fun, and like an overgrown schoolboy. It made his stories great, even when the writing was poor. His boisterous energy made his (rare) serious moments all the more powerful. Five was sweet, if a bit wet. I haven’t seen enough of the first three Doctors to give an opinion, but I have to respect everyone involved in the early years. They gave us the Doctor, and for that I will be forever grateful.

    Can you imagine a world without the Doctor?

  18. I have always been a big fan of 10, so this call is… difficult for me to handle. nonetheless, 11 is a superb doctor, so there you have it!

  19. I’m sorry, but I have to say that the tenth doctor should have won. Not only does he totally rock his converse, but 60% of Doctor Who viewers agree he is the best-(actual percentages, “People” magazine).

    • WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

  20. Not going to get into the debate (but David is my baby ok), but about the catchphrase there’s something you ought to know if you didn’t already: allon-y, as the doctor tells us once, is French for “let’s go!”, tens last words before regenerating were, “I don’t want to go” if you were not aware of this you are free to cry as much as I did

    • WHY!? Why did you bring that to my attention?! SO MUCH FEELS. :'(
      Ten is my Doctor so I am severely bias. He obviously has better hair. That was a poor judgement call. My reaction to Eleven is kind of the way that Rose reacted to Ten when Nine regenerated. Eleven is definitely beginning to grow on me. Most importantly though, and someone up there already said it, I just love the Doctor. 🙂

    • WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

    • WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

  21. Lol nope. Just nope. Honestly I’m not certain whoever wrote this has seen any Doctor Who whatsoever! (You can learn a lot about it on the Internet without becoming as involved and in love with it as actual die-hard whovians, and without ever seeing a single episode. Sorry! The hair’s been covered but honestly, if a writer could give “best acting” to Matt Smith, that writer must never have seen “Doomsday” or “The End Of Time” or “Human Nature/The Family of Blood” or “The Sound of Drums/Last of the Timelords” “The Doctor’s Daughter” “Silence in the Library” “Journey’s End” I mean, I could go on! The Tennant days of the Doctor were some of the most passionate, emotional, hysterical, astonishing days the show have ever seen! Let me give you some backstory: David Tennant grew up on Doctor Who, and Classic Who was what inspired him to even be an actor! This was his dream role and, in the majority of whovians’ opinions, he fufilled it in a way that no other actor ever can, could, or will. I’m sorry if it seems like the majority are head over heels with hipster Matt Smith right now, but it’s a FAD, promise 😉 Honestly I’m almost certain all the buzz around him won’t stand the test of time; look at the fourth doctor, now he is a doctor who’s popular, and for all the right reasons! People might forget Eleven or Seven or Nine, but they’re sure as heck never gonna forget Ten or Four. That is all =-)

    • It will be impossible to ever forget the long scarf and phrase ‘Would you like a Jelly Baby?’. And of course, the skinny Scottish bloke who yells French words like expletives.

      However, Seven is my Doctor. I think Figment should do a Classic showdown. =)

  22. I’m not sure whether to be impressed or frightened by how quickly everyone jumped on this, particularly on the award for best hair (which should go to Tennant). XD I love this fandom.

    • WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

  23. I’m mad about Eleven, although it’s always so hard to decide when I’m watching Ten in action. This went well, though, I think. <3

  24. Well I agree with this although I would argue that River should have won the best catchphrase and I also argue that Eleven should have won the companion section. Because you people are forgetting that Amy is not the only companion for Eleven. Rory, River, and Clara are also the Eleven’s companions. I know that people are going to say that River could be counted as Ten’s but they met once, besides she married Eleven so she’s much more than just a companion. Also all of Eleven’s companions have titles; Amelia Pond; The girl who waited, Rory Williams; The last centurion, River Song; the woman who married the Doctor, Clara Oswin Oswald; the girl twice dead. Only two of Ten’s companions got titles; Rose Tyler; Bad Wolf, Donna Noble; the one who forgot. And they’re pretty lame titles too. I strongly agree with the choice of best hair. Girls can pull off swoop bangs; Spiky hair, not so much.
    Another note. I’m going to argue that it’s not your first Doctor that you fall in love with; But the first Doctor you have to wait for new episodes with. I started watching after the end of the sixth season had aired but started with the ninth Doctor so technically my first Doctor was the Ninth Doctor but Eleven is my Doctor.

    • I’d like to point out that Martha had a title too ‘The Woman Who Walked the Earth’, so that’s three companions. And Sarah Jane didn’t really need a title. However, I do like Rory’s name ‘The Last Centurion’.

      But can I ask when you said ‘Girls can pull off swoop bangs; Spiky hair not so much.’ did you mean guys?

  25. Hair goes to David without a thought, unless it’s that back-comb stuff. Spikes look a lot better than a kind of floppy mop.

    Converse and 3D looks a lot more appealing at my local coffeeshop (or any geeky place) than a fez. Fezzes are bad. Fezzes are very not cool. It’s a red-velvety flowerpot.

    Best acting. How did Matt Smith win this? Yes, he got a BAFTA. But David had much more character, he could flip between ‘last of the Time Lords’ to ‘ALLONS-Y!’ to ‘I don’t want to go’. He was able to become lover, protector, savior and best friend. And he was able to portray emotion. I’m still waiting on the wow factor with Matt’s performance. Yes, he’s done well, with loving Amy and protecting her, to bringing Rory back again. Yes, when he found Clara and was amazed that was well-done, but I have yet to see a heart-wrenching episode with Smith. Angels Take Manhattan didn’t cut it. I didn’t even tear up.

    And the companion thing. How does Amy beat any of Ten’s companions? Let’s say we go with Martha, the one few people like as much. Martha still saved the world when the Master had her family, and was using them as slaves. She traveled the entire world, pretty much on foot, to tell people to bring the Doctor back so they stood a chance. Amy brought Van Gogh some sunflowers. And she never had time for Rory until the very end. Nope, not seeing how Amy could beat any of them one-on-one. Besides, Sarah Jane would kick Amelia Pond’s butt three ways from Sunday in a TARDIS.

    Don’t get me wrong, I love Smith, he’s very good. But I see more oomph in David. It’s just a guy with a bowtie trying to be cool for Smith’s version to me. I mean, next ‘hipster’ thing we get will be plugs or something. *shudder*

  26. How could Matt Smith beat Tennant on hair AND acting??? I disagree, I definitely think David Tennant should have won (but maybe I’m biased because he was my first doctor).

  27. I totally love Matt Smith as the Doctor but all of my other friends think David Tennant is the bomb. I didn’t really notice that Matt Smith said Geronimo at all until the most recent episode.

  28. Are you guys kidding me? My first doctor was 9th. I absolutely hated him. So i went back and watched from the third doctor. Yes, i honestly skipped the first two doctors, though i still have their series.

    So after watching them all except for numbers one, two, five, and six.

    The fourth doctor is definitely my favorite. Nothing is more original than, ” I know the Tardis like the back of my hand, (Staring at his palm)
    And you CANNOT beat the scarf baby.

    However, if I were to choose the best actor and story and everything, the seventh and eighth doctors really fit the Doctor Who persona. I really think the eight should have gotten a series, not just the movie… i mean cmon. He was cool, smart, and he was really good at being different.

    Finally, the Eleventh doctor just plain sucks. People need to remember that the doctor isn’t supposed to be “cool or hip” and He still looks EMO with all the stuff he has on him… Sorry Eleventh doctor fans.

    I don’t know how he won… Especially acting.

    Between these two… Tennant wins.

    My two favorite doctors are honestly The fourth and tenth.

    And trust me, Tenth definitely has better hair, looks, and acting.

    The only thing I’m tied on is the companions. Rory and River song are both AWESOME. And Amy Pond was cool too. Not my favorite.

    Donna Noble was beastly.

    No one likes Rose. No one.

    And catchphrase shouldn’t even go to the Doctor or River song, it should go to the Daleks. Or the ood.

    Example:

    “Exterminate!” –You should hear this in german. 🙂

    “We are the Ood.”

    • No offense, but how do you call yourself a Whovian? You like the fourth doctor? Have you SEEN the scarf? and the emotionless-ness? he’s like, “I must save the world. yay.” *monotone*

    • Dude. WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.
      and, Amy is the best companion, along with Sarah Jane, of course, oh and THE FIRST DOCCTOR WAS GREAT! HOW CAN YOU NOT LIKE HIS CHEEKINESS!

    • SHUT UP JUST SHUT UP SMITH IS BETTER YOU IDIOT! :ANGRY FACE: WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

    • EXCUSE ME! :flips hair: look at this mop of beauty XD joking. But Tennant still doen’t have the best hair, sure the spikes are cool but srsly look at eleven’s beautiful mop of hair (That should have a fez on it more often).

  29. DAVID TENNANT’S SPIKES ARE TO ELEVEN’S FEZ
    DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY INNOCENT FAN GIRLS HEARTS YOU’VE JUST BROKEN AND/OR MELTED AND/OR CRUSHED AND/OR STEPPED ON? EVERY DOCTOR IS THEIR OWN PERSON, YOU CANNOT JUDGE THEM BY THEIR COMPANIONS OR THEIR ACTING OR THEIR *SHUDDER* HAIR! ESPECIALLY NOT THE HAIR! EACH TIME THE DOCTOR REGENERATES, THE ONE DOCTOR DIES AND NEVER RETURNS. HOW CAN YOU JUDGE A DEAD PERSON? HOW DO YOU DO IT? IS THERE NO GUILT IN YOUR COLD, BLACK HEARTS? DOES NO ONE ELSE SEE HOW WRONG IT IS TO DECIDE WHICH DOCTOR RULES OVER ANOTHER? PERSONALLY, YOU MIGHT HAVE AN OPINION, BUT TO TELL THE WORLD WHICH DOCTOR IS BETTER? NO. JUST NO. I CAN’T BELIEVE MY FAVORITE WEBSITE WOULD DO SOMETHING LIKE THIS. I WILL NOT LOOK AT THIS PAGE AGAIN.
    Scroll quickly, for whatever holds the image of an angel, becomes itself an angel.

  30. OKAY! You guys have it wrong. I could care less if bowties are cool… David Tennant is WAY AWESOMER! He has the best hair, and some of the funniest lines like:

    Hey guys, I’m sitting in the TARDIS right now, and i’m going to wind up soon but not before I make a few strange noises with my mouth that go along the lines of “bingle bongle dingle dangle yikideedoo, yikideeda, ping pong, lippy tappy tu ta.”

    and

    People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect, but *actually* from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint – it’s more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly… time-y wimey… stuff.”

    Oh, I’m dazed and confused. I’ve been chasing this wee naked child over hill and over dale. I’nt that right, ya timorous beastie?

    And I’m not listening! Now you, Mr. Connolly, you are staring into a deep, dark pit of trouble if you don’t let me help. So I’m ordering you, sir, tell me what’s going on!

    • Eleven is better and have you not seen the scene when he’s w/ river amy and rory and then river lands it and the eleventh doctor is like “You didn’t land it what about the sound?”
      River: “what sound”
      Eleventh Doctor: “:makes a hilarius sound thats sounds slightly like the tardis materialising:”

  31. The Tenth Doctor will ALWAYS have better hair. I’ll let you go on the acting thing, even though David Tennant is brilliant, but you shall not put anybody’s hair above the Tenth Doctor’s. That is a sin.

  32. I started with Ten and Eleven, then watched Nine just recently. I love them all, but Ten will always be my favorite. And Ten will always have the best hair. Always.

  33. I love Matt Smith. He’s more than twice my age but I have a HUGE crush on him. Becasue he is beautiful and a great actor. And he has great hair.

  34. /DavidTennentisbestDoctor.

    Just saying.

    I definitely prefer Tennant’s acting, because he brought a much darker side to the Doctor’s persona. Granted, Smith can play dark at times, but most of the time it just seems like he’s a bit… to quirky to play the Doc correctly. His fashion sense is SUPERB, however. I applaud his choice on costume.

    My first Doctor was Tom Baker, even though I didn’t grow up in that era, but Tennant is still my favorite.

    So, I have to say that my final ruling, at least, is:

    David Tennant > Tom Baker > Chris Eccleston > Matt Smith.

    • I think that the 10th doctor is the best because he still has a fashion he wears just not a bow-tie or a fez he wears different types of shoes for different time periods and the 11th doctor doesn’t have that good of a hairstyle because most people don’t pay any attention of the doctor’s hairstyles he has had or other wise anyways even though I prefer the 10th doctor I think that he’s just all the same person and I rarely pay attention to which doctor its because it doesn’t matter what he looks like it just matters that he can be himself even though he has different bodies during the whole TV series.

    • WHY DO YOU LOVE DAVID TENNANT SO MUCH I STARTED WITH CHRIS AND COMPARED TO DAVID STUPIDFACE TENNANT EVEN HE IS BETTER, EVEN TERRIBLE PETER CAPALDI IS BETTER THEN (VOMIT) DAVID TENNANT. ITS NO COMPETITION ELEVEN IS. TEN… NO ELVEN TIMES BETTER THEN TENNANT. READ THE FOLLOWING TO SEE WHY:
      the tardis,David Tennan: TENNANT HIT HIS TARDIS WITH A SLEDGEHAMMER. WHO DOES THAT ITS NO WONDER THE TARDIS LIKES ELEVEN BETTER. the tardis, Matt Smith: The eleventh doctor probably had the best connection with the tardis. Not only did he understand it. He was much kinder to it than his past selves (cough cough “Ten”). He also had a whole episode dedicated `to his connection with the TARDIS (has anyone seen “The Doctor’s Wife?).
      Companion’s, Tennant: Well he has everyone’s favorite companion, Rose Tyler. But he’s also the reason she’s GONE. I personally love Rose Tyler and when she was taken out of the show because of everybody’s favorite doctor. I. WAS. MAD. He also had Martha Jones, whom he treated terribly, because she isn’t his “Rose”, well Ten your the reason she’s gone so you have nothing to defend yourself with (does a smug smile). And if you didn’t forget, Tennant is the reason Martha’s family were TORTURED. OH AND DON’T GET ME STARTED ON DONNA NOBLE, HE LETS HER TRAVEL WITH HIM FOR ONE SEASON BEFORE HE PUTS HER IN THE LINE OF DANGER SHES ALMOST KILLED IN JOURNEY’S END. BUT WHEN HE SAVES HER HE JUST END’S UP TAKING HER MEMORY?! OH AND IN THAT SAME EPISODE ROSE FIND’S TEN AND THEN HE JUST DUMP’S HER BACK IN A PARALLEL WORLD WITH HIS DUMB COPY AFTER SHE WORKED FOR SO LONG TO GET BACK TO HIM!? Companion’s, Eleventh Doctor: Amy Pond. She loved her raggedy man so very much. She waited twelve years for Eleven to come back for her. I’m sure he would have gotten her sooner but that was a fixed point in time and we all saw how well it turned out when River Song broke one of those point’s. WHICH BRING’S UP ANOTHER POINT. HE’S THE REASON AMY POND’S DAUGHTER AND THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR’S WIFE ARE DEAD. Anyway’s back to Amy. Amy had a fierce loyalty to the Eleventh Doctor. And she traveled for him for pretty much his whole eleventh incarnation, joined sometimes by her husband, Rory. Up until the tragic incident in “The Angels Take Manhatten”. And even then it wasn’t eleven’s fault, he told Rory to get into the TARDIS along with Amy. Amy did so. But then Rory saw his gravestone, and as much as I love Rory W. I have to say, it’s his fault he and Amy died in the past. Then there was his depression. After being so sad about the Pond’s\William’s unlike with any other companion’s he lived isolated from the world for years. Until Clara Oswald convinced him to save the world once more. Speaking of his “Impossible Girl” I despise her very much, but, the eleventh doctor took good care of her and tried not to put her in the line of fire unlike the twelfth doctor who is the reason eleven’s “impossible girl” is gone.
      Comparison to the original’s, Tennant: Nothing similar. Everything is diffrent! Not that change is bad, but it put’s him diffrent then the other dotors. Comparision to the original’s eleventh doctor: Oh Matt Smith is quite similar to the older doctor’s but at the same time quite original. As an example, his fez, the second doctor wore them all the time, whereas the eleventh doctor loved fezzes and all, but it never became a permanent hat, one of my favorite scenes of the eleventh doctor is actually the scene when River Song takes a fez of eleven’s head and throw’s it in the sky for Amy Pond to blast apart (this scene is in the 5th season finaly).
      Am I starting to get my point threw? If not then read the part I am writing below:

      David Tennant may have more fans but eleven is right on his tail. Eleven got an award for his fabulous work as the eleventh doctor. did ten? No. Also if you haven’t noticed ten’s companion’s only lasted one season each because, why? Because he didn’t bother to keep them with him longer, then there’s eleven who didn’t loose any of his companion’s because of his own fault. Also Matt Smith is one of the only Doctor’s that competes with the famous tenth doctor, well everyone doubted Matt would be able to top the famous Tennant, but Matt Smith, the youngest doctor in Doctor Who his, and probably the least experienced, has done it.

  35. You gave hair to smith?! Seriously though, this article is wrong on so many levels! Best outfit for me is tennants, even though ill accept smith on this one because the doctor is meant to be quirky. But hair?! Spikes versus mop head? Bullshit! And acing would have to go to tennant. Smith is just too 2D. Smiley face, frowny face, pouty face. Patronizing tone, whiny tone, shouting. Yet no real emotion. When tennants doctor was sad i wanted to reach through the screen and comfort him. With smith i wanted to yell cut and tell him that a crinkled forehead and slightly glassy eyes doesnt make it look like hes crying. I also liked 10s companions better, with the exception of martha.

  36. I can’t choose between the two of the Doctors, both are amazing. in acting, dressing, they are both funny and they both make the show exiting and worth watching. But i must insist, i prefer David’s hair and clothes.

  37. Okay,
    Responding to some previous comments,

    All three of tens companions have names….

    Rose: bad wolf
    Donna: the most important woman
    Martha: the girl who walked the earth

    ^pretty good names in my opinion^

    Now if you argue that 11 has better companions that’s your opinion. But honestly I couldn’t connect with them.

    How many of you had a crazy man jump into your backyard? Or learn that your not the real you and there are infinite duplicates? Or that you were raised to murder someone?

    Let me ask again…

    How many of you have ever questioned if you were important?
    How many of you can relate to being a shopgirl or a temp or a nurse with an ordinary job and an ordinary life? I think 9/10 of us can.

    10 has better companions because they are relatable we can put ourself in that situation and feel special and we can relate! I cant relate to ANY of moffats characters!

  38. Um, Matt Smith has never won a BAFTA. He was nominated as the Doctor, but he didn’t win. David Tennant, on the other hand, has won an Emmy (and many other awards too, including BAFTA Cymru for the Doctor). If you’re going to base the best acting point on awards won, I think you’ll find (if you look at real sources, not internet rumor) that you gave it to the wrong guy.

  39. ohh come on david tennant’s acting is incredible !! in season 4 episode 10 (midnight) when the alien is zapping him of his life the fear shown on his face is incredible. no one can emote that much he is just amazing . TENTH DOCTOR FOR EVER!!

  40. I must disagree with most of the things sorry, i get that eleven was good, but when ten left, the episodes that followed always had a gap, this gap wasn’t there during ten’s time,and therefore David as the best acting the best acting, second tens spike hair cant be beaten by eleven’s that is no way, i’m killing you for saying that (LOL joking), I do not agree with the clothes as well, elevens things have no way to beat ten’s Converse, trench, 3D glasses, and sonic screwdriver combo!i do agree for the catshphrase “Allons-y” it was the best, did you know that, the tenth doctor used to say “allons-y” which in french means “lets go”, and the last sentence he said was “i dont want to go” *ill go cry* I do agree about the compagnions as well,Amy is amazing, but doesnt beat Rose at all!
    by reading this you have broken the heart of all of the tenth doctor fans.
    Ten forever!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *